The 8 Best Substitutes For Brick Cheese

What can I use instead of Brick cheese? Cheddar cheese is the closest substitute to brick cheese, boasting a mild, sweet flavor and excellent melting properties. However, you can also use Limburger, Muenster, Mozzarella, Tilsit, Monterey Jack, and Tuma for a mild taste. Harvati cheese is the best vegetarian option to replace Brick cheese.

Brick cheese is a light yellow, brick-shaped, Wisconsin-born cheese. This medium-hard cheese boasts a mild, sweet flavor when young that matures into an intense, cheddar-like taste. Brick cheese is perfect for grilled sandwiches, mac and cheese, polenta, and pizza.

Unfortunately, brick cheese isn’t easy to find, so we will share the best substitutes. 

The Best Brick Cheese Substitutes

Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar is a hard, natural cow’s milk cheese with a mild flavor that sharpens as it ages. Cheddar is a versatile, affordable refrigerator staple you can use as the perfect alternative for aged brick cheese.

Use cheddar instead of brick cheese to shred, slice, or melt it over your favorite dishes, including burgers, grilled cheese sandwiches, mac and cheese, nachos, and potato-based casseroles.

Substitute Brick cheese with cheddar using equal ratios.

Limburger Cheese

Limburger cheese is a creamy, brick-shaped cheese with a mild, beefy flavor and pungent aroma that only intensifies as it ages. You can use Limburger cheese to replace Brick cheese for a sharper cheese.

Limburger cheese is delicious stacked on a cheese board, grilled cheese sandwich, sandwich with pickles, mac and cheese, gratins, and pizzas.

Limburger cheese can be overpowering in many recipes. So, use a bit less if you don’t want to alter the flavors of your dish.

Muenster Cheese

Muenster is semi-soft, pale-yellow cheese with a distinctive orange rind. Its flavors vary from a mild, buttery, nutty cheese when young to a sharp, Jack-like cheese when aged.

Muenster cheese is a suitable substitute for grilled cheese recipes if you can’t find Brick cheese.

Muenster has excellent melting properties. In addition, its mild flavors are fantastic in grilled dishes like sandwiches, mac and cheese, pizza, and burgers.

Use equal amounts of Muenster when substituting Brick cheese.

Tilsit Cheese

Tilsit cheese, also known as tilsiter cheese, is a versatile, semi-hard cheese that ranges from white to light. Tilsit cheese boasts a mild flavor with a sweet, spicy undertone.

Tilsit’s semi-hard texture makes it perfect for slicing. You can use it in salads, sauces, grilled sandwiches, and melted over potatoes or burgers.

Use equal amounts of Tilsit cheese when substituting Brick cheese.

Havarti Cheese

Havarti cheese is a semi-soft cheese with a creamy, springy texture. Young Havarti boasts mild flavors with subtly sweet, acid notes that become sharp and intense as it matures.

Havarti cheese is typically made using vegetarian-friendly rennet. However, always check the label first.

Havarti cheese’s mild taste suits most palates. Its piquant flavors harmonize well with salads, sandwiches, pasta, and burgers. You can also enjoy Harvati on a cracker with fresh toppings.

Use equal amounts of Havarti cheese when substituting brick cheese.

If you are vegetarian, double-check that Havarti cheese is made using vegetable rennet instead of animal rennet before purchasing it.


Mozzarella needs no introduction, sitting at the top of USA’s favorite cheese. This decadent, well-balanced Italian cheese is the best Brick cheese substitute for gooey pizzas.

Mozzarella’s mild taste complements any dish that calls for melted cheese without altering the flavors too much. You can use mozzarella for grilled cheese sandwiches, pizzas, and casseroles.

Use equal amounts of mozzarella when substituting brick cheese. However, mozzarella’s mild flavor allows you to go wild when topping pizzas and casseroles.

Monterey Jack Cheese

Monterey Jack cheese is an aged, semi-hard cheese with a mild, buttery flavor. Other varieties of Monterey Jack include Colby Jack and Pepper Jack.

Monterey Jack’s creamy texture and melting properties make it an ideal replacement for Bricks cheese.

You can replace Brick cheese for Monterey Jack for snacks, cheese trays, casseroles, cheeseburgers, pasta, and grilled-cheese sandwiches.

You can use equal amounts of Monterey Jack when substituting Brick cheese. However, we recommend mixing the Monterey Jack with mozzarella for a similar flavor to Brick cheese or cheddar.  

Tuma Cheese

Tuma cheese is a soft, delicate cheese with a similar appearance and texture to mozzarella.

You can replace Brick cheese with Tuma cheese for a creamy cheese that melts into a gooey, mouth-watering masterpiece.

You can add Tuma cheese to pizzas, sandwiches, and pasta for a slightly different flavor from Brick cheese.

Use equal amounts of Tuma cheese when substituting brick cheese.